Formula 420 All Natural vs Soak-N-Rinse: Which Cleaner Is Right for You?
Both products cover compatible glass, metal, Pyrex, and ceramic, and both cost the same at OSV. The useful difference is the routine: a fast natural-formula cleaner versus a no-scrub soak for smaller items.
Formula 420 All Natural vs Soak-N-Rinse at a glance
| Feature | All Natural A2 | Soak-N-Rinse S1 |
|---|---|---|
| Manufacturer positioning | All-natural cleaner | No-scrub soaking cleaner |
| Material category | Compatible glass, metal, Pyrex, and ceramic | Compatible glass, metal, Pyrex, and ceramic |
| Best item type | Pieces suited to a fast liquid-cleaning routine | Smaller removable items that can be fully soaked and rinsed |
| Agitation | Follow the bottle's current use directions | Designed to avoid shaking and scrubbing |
| Current OSV price | $11.99 | $11.99 |
| Simple verdict | Choose for the natural-formula, fast-routine preference | Choose for the hands-off soak preference |
What is the difference between Formula 420 All Natural and Soak-N-Rinse?
The official Formula 420 product-family page describes A2 All Natural as the line's all-natural cleaner for glass, metal, Pyrex, and ceramic. It describes S1 Soak-N-Rinse as a no-scrub product for smaller items in the same broad material group, with no shaking or scrubbing required.
That makes item size and handling the practical dividing line. A small removable bowl, slide, or compatible accessory can be easy to place in a suitable soaking container. A larger piece may require too much liquid, may trap cleaner in chambers, or may include decals and bonded parts that are not meant to soak. All Natural can be the more straightforward choice when the permitted item is better handled directly.
“All Natural” is a product name and manufacturer claim, not a universal safety statement. A natural-origin cleaner can still irritate, damage a finish, or be incompatible with an attached material. Likewise, “Soak-N-Rinse” does not authorize soaking every part of a device.
Which Formula 420 cleaner should you buy?
Buy All Natural A2 if:
- You specifically want Formula 420's natural-formula option
- Your compatible item suits a quick clean-and-rinse routine
- The piece is too large or complex for a practical soak
- The current bottle and care guide permit the method
Buy Soak-N-Rinse S1 if:
- Your compatible item is small and removable
- You prefer not to shake or scrub the part
- You have a suitable, secure soaking container
- You can rinse every channel and dry the part fully
When neither is the right bottle
If the accessory is plastic, acrylic, or silicone, do not choose between A2 and S1 by guesswork. Formula 420 makes a separate Plastics/Silicone product for that material category. OSV's complete Formula 420 cleaner guide compares all three currently stocked options.
If the main problem is concentrate residue on compatible glass, compare the brand's concentrate-focused formulas in OSV's Formula 710 Instant vs Advanced guide.
How to use either cleaner more safely
- Check the current label. Use its amount, contact time, agitation, rinse, protective-equipment, and first-aid instructions.
- Confirm accessory compatibility. Check the maker's care guide for the material, finish, printed graphics, seals, and bonded components.
- Cool and disassemble. Never clean a hot part. Remove batteries and electronics, and only separate components the manufacturer says are removable.
- Ventilate. Poison Control advises reading labels, ventilating the area, and never mixing cleaning products.
- Use one product. Do not combine Formula 420 with alcohol, bleach, or another cleaner.
- Rinse and dry fully. Make sure no liquid remains in narrow airpaths, joints, or cavities before reassembly.
- Store securely. The CPSC recommends original containers and locked storage away from children.
For the full disassembly and drying process, use OSV's seven-step glass-cleaning guide.
Shop Formula 420 All Natural and Soak-N-Rinse
Both products were available for $11.99 in OSV's live inventory on July 14, 2026. Check the current product page before ordering.
Formula 420 All Natural A2
The direct-routine choice for compatible glass, metal, Pyrex, and ceramic.
$11.99
Shop All Natural
Formula 420 Soak-N-Rinse S1
The hands-off soaking choice for compatible smaller glass, metal, Pyrex, and ceramic items.
$11.99
Shop Soak-N-RinseBrowse the full Formula 420 collection or compare all cleaning supplies.
Formula 420 A2 vs S1 FAQ
Is Formula 420 All Natural better than Soak-N-Rinse?
Not universally. All Natural is better for buyers who want that formula and a direct routine. Soak-N-Rinse is better for compatible smaller items when a no-scrub soak is more convenient.
Are both cleaners safe for glass?
The manufacturer lists compatible glass in both material categories, but the exact piece still matters. Check for coatings, decals, glued parts, and separate manufacturer restrictions.
Can Soak-N-Rinse clean a whole bong?
Only if the current label and the piece maker permit the process, and if every chamber can be rinsed and dried. The product is positioned for smaller items, so a full-size bong may be impractical.
Does All Natural mean non-toxic?
Do not infer that from the name. Treat it as a cleaner, read the hazard and first-aid label, ventilate, avoid contact, and store it securely.
How long should I soak an item?
Use the contact time on the current Soak-N-Rinse label. Do not extend it based on a blog or an older bottle.
Can I use either cleaner on silicone?
Do not assume so. Formula 420 offers a separate Plastics/Silicone formula. Check the item's care instructions and the selected cleaner label.
Research and safety sources
For adults 21 and older. Use only on compatible accessories and follow the current bottle label. Never mix cleaners. Keep cleaning products in their original containers, locked away from children and pets.